How to Make Mashed Potatoes

Mashed potatoes is a classic American dish. Its main ingredients are potatoes and milk. This recipe will walk you through step by step.

Rating
(1)
Total time
45 min
Yield
10 servings
Updated
Updated

By Mari & Jacob Petrosky
Cooked, filmed, and tested in our Arizona kitchen

Mashed Potatoes in a bowl

Mashed potatoes are a classic American dish. Its main ingredients are potatoes and milk. Usually served on special occasions like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and other holidays. I discovered that my husband makes creamy and delicious mashed potatoes. So from then on, he’s been the designated Mashed Potatoes dude on any holidays in hour household. ;-P.

You can find the ingredients for this awesome dish in your local grocery store. So drop what you’re doing right now and let’s all learn how to make my husband’s America Classic Mashed Potatoes.


Play video: How to make mashed potatoes step by step

Ingredients

  • 8-10 large russet potatoes
  • 2-4 gallons water, at room temperature (for soaking the potatoes)
  • 3-4 quarts water, at room temperature (for boiling the potatoes)
  • 1 can (fl oz) evaporated milk
  • ¾ tbsp salt
  • ¾ tbsp black pepper
  • 1 stick salted butter (divided)

Things you’ll need

  • Peeler
  • Cutting board
  • Knives
  • Large Mixing bowl
  • Large pot
  • A stand mixer (you may also use a potato masher if preferred)

Instructions

Skin the potatoes:

peeling mashed potatoes

Put 2-4 gallons of water in the sink. Soak and clean 8-10 russet potatoes. Using a peeler, peel each potato and soak them in a separate mixing bowl with water (preferably drinking water). Cut them into 1″ chunk. Make sure to put the wedges of potatoes back into the water to prevent them from darkening. Set aside for later.

Cook the potatoes:

cooking mashed potatoes

In a large pot, boil 3-4 quarts of water over high heat. When water is boiling add the wedges of potatoes, mix them around and scoop out some water to prevent a boil over. Cover and let it boil for 20-30 minutes over medium heat or until cooked.

Prep:

prepping ingredients for mashed potatoes

Meantime, in a separate mixing bowl, pour 1 can of evaporated milk. Add 3/4 tbsp of salt and 3/4 tbsp of black pepper. Then add 6 tbsp of salted butter. Put the remaining butter to the side for later.

Mix:

mixing mashed potatoes

After 25 minutes, fish out a wedge of potato and check to see if it’s soft all the way through. When cooked, turn the stove off. Drain the water and transfer the cooked potatoes into the milk mixture. Set it up in the stand mixer. Attach the wire whip and begin mixing over low speed. Increase the speed as necessary until it becomes soft. Occasionally stop the mixer and push the potato towards the center then continue to mix. Add the remaining butter into the bowl but you can make it how you like it. Continue mixing until the mashed potato becomes soft and creamy.

If you enjoyed this classic American dish. Check out our video on how to make Pasta Salad.

Recipe card

Mashed Potato Recipe

Mashed potatoes are a classic American dish. Its main ingredients are potatoes and milk. Usually served on special occasions like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and other holidays. I discovered that my husband makes creamy and delicious mashed potatoes. So from then on, he’s been the designated Mashed Potatoes dude on any holidays in hour household. ;-P. You […]

1 review American Dinner
Prep time
15 min
Cook time
30 min
Total time
45 min
Yield
10 servings

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to check it off.

Some ingredient links in the article point to Amazon so you can see the exact products we use. We earn nothing from them.

Instructions

  1. 1

    Skin the potatoes

    Put 2-4 gallons of water in the sink. Soak and clean 8-10 russet potatoes. Using a peeler, peel each potato and soak them in a separate mixing bowl with water (preferably drinking water). Cut them into 1" chunk. Make sure to put the wedges of potatoes back into the water to prevent them from darkening. Set aside for later.

    peeling mashed potatoes
  2. 2

    Cook the potatoes

    In a large pot, boil 3-4 quarts of water over high heat. When water is boiling add the wedges of potatoes, mix them around and scoop out some water to prevent a boil over. Cover and let it boil for 20-30 minutes over medium heat or until cooked.

    cooking mashed potatoes
  3. 3

    Prep the ingredients

    Meantime, in a separate mixing bowl, pour 1 can of evaporated milk. Add 3/4 tbsp of salt and 3/4 tbsp of black pepper. Then add 6 tbsp of salted butter. Put the remaining butter to the side for later.

    prepping ingredients for mashed potatoes
  4. 4

    Mix the ingredients

    After 25 minutes, fish out a wedge of potato and check to see if it's soft all the way through. When cooked, turn the stove off. Drain the water and transfer the cooked potatoes into the milk mixture. Set it up in the stand mixer. Attach the wire whip and begin mixing over low speed. Increase the speed as necessary until it becomes soft. Occasionally stop the mixer and push the potato towards the center then continue to mix. Add the remaining butter into the bowl but you can make it how you like it. Continue mixing until the mashed potato becomes soft and creamy.

    mixing mashed potatoes
Nutrition facts 214 per 1 cup serving
Calories
214
Fat
7g
Saturated fat
1.4g
Unsaturated fat
0g
Trans fat
0.3g
Cholesterol
0mg
Sodium
741mg
Carbohydrates
35g
Fiber
3.1g
Sugar
1.2g
Protein
4g
Serving size
1 cup

Estimates calculated from the ingredients as written; actual values vary with brands and portions.

Reader reviews

1 cook rated this recipe

4.5out of 5

  • Dusaun Anton

    Dec 9, 2020

    Never thought of using canned milk. Very simple recipe.

You might also like

Keep cooking

Browse all recipes
American Dinner

How To Make Cast Iron Bread Rolls

Let's learn how to make bread machine cast iron rolls. This bread roll recipe is very easy to follow and the bread rolls are super soft, airy, and delicious.

Every recipe has a video

Cook along with us on YouTube

Mari films every step so you can see exactly what the dough, the sauce, or the sear should look like. Subscribing is free and helps us keep this site ad-free.

Subscribe